Nutrition
Carbohydrates
NOTE: Nutrition cannot realistically be fragmented, or divided, into its individual nutrients (protein, fat, carbohydrates, vitamins, minerals, etc.). A whole food is exponentially superior to the sum of its measurable nutrients. In speaking of fragmented terms such as “protein,” “carbohydrate,” and “fat,” we must always remember that real food comes in a whole form.
Carbohydrates
Have all the sugar you want, as long as you eat it in whole plant foods.
What is a Carbohydrate?
Carbohydrates, called “carbs” for short, are, chemically speaking, hydrated carbons, hence the name carbo- (carbon) hydrates (hydrated, meaning water). Carbon and water are the foundation of life on earth, including both our food and our bodies. Carbohydrates are the ideal source of food and energy for our bodies.
The basic unit of carbohydrates is glucose, which is a simple (one-molecule, or monosaccharide) sugar. There are other types of simple sugars, such as fructose, dextrose, and galactose, which all have slightly different forms but are still very similar to glucose, and which are converted into glucose in the body because glucose is the basic source of energy in the body. Blood glucose, also called blood sugar, the measurement of the amount of glucose in the blood, is an indicator of our ability to utilize glucose (insulin “sensitivity”).
Starches are complex carbohydrates, meaning they are made up of many glucose sugars stuck together in different ways. When we eat starch, in the form of whole plant foods (vegetables, fruits, and nuts), our bodies cleave (or cut) off the glucose units bit by bit to provide us with a continuous supply of energy, keeping a steady “blood sugar.” Another type of complex carbohydrate is fiber.
Fiber is also a complex carbohydrate, but it is unique in that we don’t actually digest or even absorb it. Fiber remains in our digestive tract, pulling toxins, nourishing our microbiome, and affecting how other nutrients are absorbed. Fiber slows absorption of glucose from other carbohydrates so we don’t absorb it all at once, thus helping us maintain steady blood glucose (Fiber). That’s just another reason why food must be eaten in the whole form, and not extracted and processed outside the body.
Do Carbs Make Me Fat?
No. Carbohydrates are not the cause of body fat. It is true that extracting carbohydrates out of whole foods and eating them as sugars and “food products” is indeed very harmful to the body in many ways, causing blood sugar, hormonal, and microbiome disturbances. But the body is very slow to make fat out of carbohydrate (Fernández-Quintela). Comparatively small amounts of fat may be made from high amounts of processed carbohydrates (sugars and processed foods), but the large bulk of our body fat matches our dietary fat – meaning that we store the fat we eat (Fernández-Quintela).
Sugar, Honey, Agave, and Other Sweeteners
Any added sweetener – including sugar, honey, agave, corn syrup, etc. – is dehydrating and temporarily disturbs blood sugar balance because it is an uncontrolled surge of glucose (resulting in a surge then drop in blood sugar). Artificial sweeteners, such as erythritol, are promoted as healthful because they have no carbohydrates, but “zero calorie” is not “zero effect.” Carbs or no carbs, when the body tastes sweetness, it responds as though it were receiving carbohydrates. Insulin lowers blood glucose, and since the artificial sweeteners provide no carbohydrate, the blood glucose may drop too low and cause more craving for sugar to normalize the blood glucose. Artificial sweeteners, such as aspartame, can also be excitotoxic.
Sweetness is best enjoyed in the whole-food form, such as fruits, melons, and baked sweet potatoes. The All Wholesome Herbs recipe book may be helpful to you in learning to appreciate the sweetness of whole plant foods without any added sweeteners.
Sweet Tooth
It is for good reason that we have a natural appetite for sweetness. Our best nutrition comes from high-carbohydrate whole plant foods such as berries, sweet potatoes, peaches, tomatoes, potatoes, and every other wholesome herb. Our maximum health will not come in attempting to squelch our sweet tooth, but rather in directing that appetite to the whole plant foods our bodies – and appetites – call for.
RESEARCH
Eastwood M, et al. Dietary Fiber: How Did We Get Where We Are? Annual Review of Nutrition, 25:1-8, 2005.
Fiber. Micronutrient Information Center, Linus Pauling Institute, Oregon State University. Mar. 2019.
Fernández-Quintela A, et al. The Role of Dietary Fat in Adipose Tissue Metabolism. Public Health Nutrition, 10(10A): 1126-1131, Oct. 2007.